|
Islam for the Christian., July 31, 2001 Reviewer: A reader
from Oregon As my title suggests this is a pretty decent overview
of Islam. It is not an in depth look at all facets of
the Islamic faith, but it is its a good dissection of the faith's
core values. While Muslim apologists are sprouting all over the
'net, it's good to have some balance to their rhetoric. The Qur'an
and Hadith, despite what they will have you believe, are filled
with violence, hatred, racism, misogynistic rants and blatant
contradictions.
Understanding what the Qur'an and Hadith is all about can
help you not only understand what's going on in the Middle East,
but your Muslim neighbors. I took away a few stars because the
author would continually cite personal conversations with various
Muslims. I don't believe this is credible enough evidence. After
all, how many times have various kooks claimed to be Christian
and their words taken as being orthodox thought? Lastly, I would
say this book is a good addition to an Christian's library. I
would also suggest getting a copy of the Qur'an and Hadith if
you do a lot of witnessing to Muslims. If the Christian is interested
only affirming that Islam is a false faith. Just the fact
that Islam denies the deity of Christ, the Trinity, the authority
of the Bible and salvation through Grace is plenty of evidence
of that. God bless.
WHAT IF ISLAM RULED AMERICA, a reader from Middle-East states
that DR.Morey is giving good examples about what if Islam ruled
America, what it would be like. From Islamic laws and sources:-
Islam is more than a religion; It is a comprehensive
way of life. The Quran (believed by Muslims to be Allah's
word), and the Hadith (Mohammed's sayings as recorded by Al Bukhari),
prescribe numerous regulations governing every aspect of the
social, political, economical, as well as religious life. The
belief that (Islam is a religion and a state) is an integral
part of the Islamic religion. Let's examine what Islam would
do if it ruled America. What would happen to the values and institutions
that we hold dear?
First: LIBERTY This country was built on the Bill of Rights,
established by the founding fathers who came here to escape religious
oppression. The Constitution gives citizens the right to express
themselves as they please, criticize the president, to worship
in the way they want and to act in any way they see appropriate
as long as they don't violate the rights of others. What would
happen to this freedom in an Islamic state? Would the citizens
be granted the right to choose the religion they want or would
they be forced into Islam.
According to the Quranic verse: "If anyone desires a
religion other than Islam, never will it be accepted of him,
and in the hereafter he will be in the ranks of those who have
lost." (Surah 3:85) How about the right of a Muslim to change
his own religion? Would he be given this right or would he be
punished according to the apostasy rule which states that such
a person should be punished by death? Mohammed said "Whoever
changes his religion, kill him." (Al Buhkari Vol. 9:57)
Do Muslims activists want us to have the same rights granted
to the citizens of an Islamic country such as Saudi Arabia, where
women are not allowed to drive an automobile and no one can worship
openly according to any religion other than Islam? Do they want
us to be ruled by a ruler such as Khomeini, who issued an order
to murder a writer, Salman Rushdie, just because he dared to
criticize Islam?
Even in a moderate Islamic state such as Egypt, Christians
have to obtain a presidential decree to be able to build a church,
or even repair a toilet in a church. They face discrimination
in all aspects of their lives, including education, employment
and promotions.
Second: DEMOCRACY Our present system in the USA gives citizens
the right to rule themselves, to write the laws that will govern
their lives, to decide the amount of taxes to be collected from
them and how it will be spent. One important principle in this
great system is the separation of church and state. Islam, however,
is built on an opposing concept, for "Islam is a religion
and a state."
According to Islam, the Quran is the principal source of legislation:
" We have sent down to thee the book in truth, that you
might judge men as guided by God." (Surah 4:105) If the
Quran is the law, what are some of the rules and regulations
that will be imposed? Here are just a few examples: STEALING:
punished by hand amputation. (Surah 5:41) ADULTERY: punished
by public flogging. (Surah 24:2) DRINKING: punished by 40 or
80 lashes. the third offense, the drinker should be executed
(Al Bukhari 8:770) RESISTING ISLAM: punished by death, crucifixion,
or the cutting off of hands and feet. (Surah 5:36) Prisons in
Muslim countries are known to be centers of torture rather than
rehabilitation.
Third: EQUALITY Under our system in the United States, there
should be no discrimination among citizens based on sex, color,
religion or race. Would Islam treat men and women equally when:
It teaches that men are superior to women? (Surah 2:228) It gives
men double the share of women in inheritance? (Surah 4:11) It
gives the man double the value of a woman's witness in court?
(Surah 2:282)
Would Islam treat non-Muslims fairly when: The Quran calls
on Muslims not to befriend Jews or Christians? (Surah 9:30) The
Quran imposes "Jizya" (tribute tax) on Christians and
Jews that will be collected only from them and not from Muslims?
(Surah 9:29) Mohammed says that a Muslim may not be killed if
he kills a non-Muslim." No Muslim should be killed for killing
a kafir (infidel or non-Muslim.)" (Al Bukhari Vol. 9:50)
COULD ISLAM SOMEDAY RULE AMERICA? Islam is the fastest growing
religion in America. Today, the number of followers of Islam
in the United States has reached 4 to 6 million. It is expected
that Islam will be the second largest religion in America before
the turn of the century from immigration,marriage,converting,
and, it is only a matter of time before Islam will become the
religion of the majority. America, then, will be labeled an "Islamic
country", ruled by the "Quran" and the "Hadith"or
what Muslims call Sharia (the Islamic code of ethics).
Brave Man, reviewed from Scotland. Robert Morey should be
applauded for having the nerve to tell the truth about the cult
of the Moon God (Islam) and its roots. Westerners would
be well advised to read this demistifying of the Islamic creed
rather than assume that because it comes from somewhere else
then it is somehow more magical. As usual the other reviews of
this text say "oh but the Christian Bible says this"
and then attempt to offer evidence from the Old Testament. There
are two points that need to be made here.
Firstly Dr Morey makes it clear on several occasions that
he is attempting to review the self-contradiction of the Quran
(not the Bible!) and offers countless other sources of supporting
information many from Muslim scholars.
Secondly, that the term "Christian Bible" is used
so often by other reviewers when quoting the Old Testament shows
a fundamental lack of understanding of the topic. Any review
of the Christian faith requires the New Testament and the teachings
of Jesus (the Christ - hence the name) to be complete.
Christianity does not claim the works of the Old Testament
as exclusively it's own as they are shared with the Jewish faith.
Consequently those who may think they are "having a go"
at Christianity are more properly attacking Judaism. For those
interested in learning the truth about Islam this is an invaluable
starting text and a highly readable book. |